Account · 2 tweets

John Ennis

@johnennis ↗

Tweets

John Ennis @johnennis
Skeptical

Few would even really consider whether Jev or FSD are conscious if there were no LLMs around, they would just be considered useful pieces of software In fact, I’ve never heard anyone argue that nano banana pro is conscious What’s different about the LLM is that they give text-based output, which activates the mirror neurons in our brain and hijacks our social infrastructure, so that it is easy to get mesmerized into thinking that there is a mind on the other side of those words But there is no mind there, it is an illusion The world‘s greatest puppet show

retweets 58 likes 356 substance 6 · argument · rank 208 · LLMs lack a mind; their text output merely tricks our brains into imagining consciousness. view on X ↗
2 top replies
Mehmed II @lorde_russell

lmfaooo yeah no says Nano banana is conscious lol

I think nanobanana pro might be a multi-modal LLM, so they would be conscious for the same reason any other LLM is. If you want to replace nanobanana with Midjourney in that statement, then what's different about the LLM isn't just text. If MJ is sentient somehow, it still

John Ennis @johnennis
Skeptical

I think it is more likely that trees are conscious than that transformers can produce consciousness There is simply no mechanism for transformers to support a persistent self that can have subjective experiences Trees at least have persistence through time, so who knows

retweets 14 likes 181 substance 6 · argument · rank 168 · Transformers cannot produce consciousness because they lack a mechanism to support a persistent self. view on X ↗
1 top reply
Jerry Howell @J3rryH0well

No experience is subjective though. An experience by it's very nature is objective only.